Skip to content

How to Grade Your Fantasy Football Team After the Draft ​

What a useful team grader should measure beyond projected points
Written by Kevin Tian

Getting a player later than his average draft position feels like a win. But if he's your third quarterback in a one-QB league and you still need a starting receiver, the bargain needs some explaining.

I'd read a draft grade in two passes: check the price paid for each player, then check whether those picks produced a usable lineup. Below, I'll work through both, including a sample calculation from the ffwrapped draft grader.

The numbers and roster situations in the examples are illustrative. They are not results from a user's league or recommendations for current players.

Current Roster Grade vs Draft Grade ​

Suppose you drafted a weak RB2, then found a starter on waivers in Week 3. Your team got better, but that pickup doesn't make the original draft pick better.

A draft grade evaluates the completed draft. A current roster grade evaluates the players you own now, including trades and waiver additions. Use ffwrapped Rate My Team for the current roster, or the draft grader to review draft night.

What I Want a Draft Grade to Measure ​

A draft grade does not need to be complicated. I would start with five things:

  • Starting lineup strength
  • Value compared to average draft position
  • Positional balance
  • Bench upside
  • Fit with league settings

The league settings are the part people skip, even though they change almost everything. A team can look great in full-PPR and a lot less exciting in standard scoring. Quarterbacks matter completely differently in superflex. Deep benches make upside picks more valuable. Short benches make it harder to justify holding players who need a lot to go right.

For more on format differences, read Half-PPR vs Full-PPR: Which Fantasy Football Scoring Format Is Better?. Commissioners can also use Fantasy Football League Rules to Decide Before Draft Day before the draft starts.

Read ADP Value in the Right Direction ​

ADP means average draft position. A lower pick number is earlier and costs more draft capital. For a simple price comparison, subtract ADP from the actual pick number:

text
ADP value = actual pick number - ADP
Illustrative pickActual pickADPDifferenceWhat the price tells you
Receiver A3852-14Taken 14 picks earlier than average: a reach relative to ADP
Running back B9578+17Taken 17 picks later than average: value relative to ADP

Pick 38 against ADP 52 is a reach. Pick 95 against ADP 78 is value. That describes the price, not whether the player will have a good season. Use ADP for a comparable format and draft period; a superflex market is a poor reference for a one-QB draft.

I'd still consider Receiver A at 38 if he were the last player in a tier I trusted and I didn't expect him to reach my next pick. I would write down that reason rather than call the pick a discount. Running back B might be a useful bargain, but I'd check his role and why he fell before celebrating.

How ffwrapped Grades a Completed Draft ​

For a standard pick-based draft, ffwrapped combines projected points and ADP value for each selection:

text
pick contribution = projected season points / 10 + (actual pick number - ADP)

Give Receiver A an illustrative projection of 200 points and Running back B a projection of 150:

PickProjection componentADP componentContribution to team score
Receiver A200 / 10 = 2038 - 52 = -146
Running back B150 / 10 = 1595 - 78 = +1732

These contributions are grading inputs, not predicted fantasy scores. The formula rewards the later price on Running back B enough to outweigh Receiver A's larger projection in this example. You can disagree with how much that should matter, but you can see where the difference comes from.

A manager's first 13 selections contribute to the team total. ffwrapped then compares that total with the other managers in the same draft room:

text
relative score = (team total - league mean) / league standard deviation

For a complete grading example, suppose the first 13 picks sum to 280, the league mean is 250, and its standard deviation is 40. The relative score is (280 - 250) / 40 = 0.75, which maps to A- in ffwrapped. Those are assumed sample totals, not a calculation from the two picks above. In a draft where every team has the same total, the relative score is set to zero rather than dividing by zero.

That A- means the team scored well against this draft room under this formula. It is not a championship probability or a claim that every starting position is covered. Auction drafts use a separate bid-value calculation; the pick-number example above does not apply to them.

You can grade a completed Sleeper, ESPN, or Yahoo draft and inspect its picks. If your league uses third-round reversal, use the actual pick numbers from that draft when comparing prices.

Check the Roster Behind the Grade ​

Now imagine that sample A- belongs to a 12-team, one-QB roster with two RB slots, two WR slots, a TE, and one RB/WR/TE flex. The manager drafted three quarterbacks and just three receivers.

Roster detailWhat I'd checkHow it changes my assessment
All starting slots are filledCompare projected starters with the rest of the leagueThe lineup may still deserve the strong grade
Two quarterbacks sit on the benchCheck whether either would realistically replace the starterA good ADP price doesn't make both useful every week
All three receivers must start when one fills the flexLook for another eligible flex and coverage for WR absencesThe roster has little room for a receiver injury or bye
A late running back fell below ADPCheck his workload and the alternatives available at that pickThe discount helps only if the player becomes useful

My note on that draft would be: good prices, but too much bench space at quarterback and too little receiver cover. I'd look for a suitable receiver on waivers or a trade partner who needs a quarterback. I wouldn't assume the extra quarterbacks have trade value just because I drafted them.

This is a manual interpretation of the sample roster. The numerical formula above doesn't directly score each of these roster-construction details, so I wouldn't quietly turn the A- into a different official grade. I'd keep the grade and the concern side by side.

ffwrapped Draft Grades vs ESPN Draft Grades ​

If ESPN and ffwrapped give the same roster different grades, start with the picks where they disagree. Is one report treating a player as a bargain? Is the concern about a weak starting position? A letter by itself won't explain that.

ffwrapped's standard draft calculation is shown above. Consult ESPN's Draft Report Card documentation for its explanation rather than assuming the two grades measure exactly the same thing. I'd keep the useful observations from each report instead of averaging their letters.

Save the Grade and Check It Later ​

Save the grade and one sentence about the pick you most want to revisit. For the A- team above, mine would be: “Who starts at receiver during the bye weeks?” After the byes, check the box scores and the weekly power rankings. Maybe that hole cost the team a game. Maybe they fixed it with a $2 waiver claim.

For more preseason strategy, start with the Fantasy Football Draft Strategy Guide, use the draft-night preparation checklist, or see which draft slots produced the most champions across 580 Sleeper leagues.

Fantasy Football Team Grader FAQ ​

How can I grade my fantasy football team? ​

To rate the roster you own now, compare its projected starting lineup, position groups, and depth with every other current roster in the league using ffwrapped Rate My Team. To evaluate how you drafted, the ffwrapped draft grader calculates pick and team grades for a completed Sleeper, ESPN, or Yahoo draft.

What is the difference between a team grader and a draft analyzer? ​

A current team grader evaluates the roster as it exists now, including changes made after the draft. A draft analyzer evaluates the completed picks. ffwrapped's standard calculation uses ADP value and projected points relative to the other teams in the room; the manual roster check above adds context the score can miss.

Can a fantasy football team rank highly with a bad draft grade? ​

Yes. Draft grades are preseason snapshots. Waivers, trades, injuries, and lineup decisions can turn a weak draft into a strong season, while a highly graded roster can fall apart after draft night.

Last updated: