Best Fantasy Football Draft Slot? What 580 Sleeper Leagues Show
Almost 3,000 unique fantasy football leagues were added to ffwrapped for the 2024 season. Among them were 580 12-team redraft leagues, which gave me a chance to answer two questions I hear every August: what is the best fantasy football draft slot, and how much does that starting position really matter?
For each of those 580 leagues I noted where the eventual champion picked in Round 1. I wanted to know whether I'd still want an early pick after seeing who was actually on the board in 2024.
Championship Rate by Draft Position
The results show a slight advantage for managers with later draft positions. Picks 7 through 12 accounted for 58.1% of the champions, with picks 10 and 11 producing the most winners.
The player pool helps explain why. Managers picking late often left the first turn with two players from a productive group that included A.J. Brown, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Saquon Barkley, Jahmyr Gibbs, Kyren Williams, Josh Jacobs, and Jonathan Taylor.
The first three draft positions had a much rougher year. Christian McCaffrey, the near unanimous first pick, missed most of the season. Still, 13 managers in this dataset won a championship after drafting him. That is a nice reminder that even a terrible first-round outcome does not end the season.
CeeDee Lamb, Tyreek Hill, and Breece Hall also went in the top three of many drafts and fell short of expectations. I took Hill with the third pick in my own league, so I was not surprised to see that only 19 champions in the dataset had drafted him in the first round.
League Winners
Ja'Marr Chase appears on more championship rosters than anyone else in the dataset. He was usually the third or fourth receiver drafted, in part because of his contract situation, but finished the season as the clear WR1.
Health is a common theme among the most frequent league winners. Chase, Jefferson, Brown, Robinson, and Barkley did not miss a game because of injury. Jonathan Taylor is the interesting exception. He missed three games and finished as RB9, but scored 39.8 points in Week 16 and 26.6 in Week 17, exactly when his managers needed him most.
Player Positions
Most champions started with a running back or wide receiver. Thirty-nine of them, or 6.7%, took a quarterback in the first round. Those picks were Lamar Jackson (13), Josh Allen (9), Patrick Mahomes (5), Jalen Hurts (4), C.J. Stroud (3), Anthony Richardson (2), Joe Burrow (1), Brock Purdy (1), and Dak Prescott (1).
Lamar Jackson, Josh Allen, and Joe Burrow finished as the top three quarterbacks. The rest were not exactly league winners on their own. Some of those managers probably recovered by finding Baker Mayfield or Jayden Daniels later.
Three champions were bold enough to draft Mark Andrews in the first round. Their scoring settings may have been unusual, but winning after spending a first pick on the TE5 is still impressive.
So, What Was the Best Fantasy Football Draft Slot?
If I got a do-over on that draft, I'd take 10 or 11. Picking late meant two shots at that group of backs and receivers before the board came back to the manager at 1.03.
The result I keep coming back to is those 13 McCaffrey managers who won anyway. I'd love to see their waiver history. The draft grades tell you what they left the room with, but I'd want to know who actually started for them in the final.
See what happened in your own draft
Connect a completed Sleeper, ESPN, or Yahoo draft to compare every pick with ADP, projections, roster construction, and the other teams in your league.
For more preseason context, read What Is Third-Round Reversal (3RR)? or the Fantasy Football Draft Strategy Guide. For a more technical walkthrough, read How to use the Sleeper API.