Skip to content

Early-Season Fantasy Football Disappointments: Hold or Bench? ​

What changed for Achane, Pollard, and Loveland heading into Week 4
Written by Kevin Tian

Updated September 29, 2026, after Week 3. The advice below reflects the linked reports available that day. Recheck availability and projections before setting your Week 4 lineup.

I had Achane down as a hold, Pollard as someone to compare with my bench, and Loveland as a tight end I'd look to replace. After Week 3, the first of those calls was the one I had to change immediately.

De'Von Achane: Replace Him in Your Lineup ​

NFL.com reports that Achane's torn ACL ends his 2026 season. My previous recommendation to keep starting him no longer applies.

In redraft, I'd use the roster spot to find an available replacement, checking any roster restrictions first. In dynasty or keeper leagues, I'd look at the IR rules and the cost of keeping him before making a roster move. Those formats call for a different decision than filling this week's RB slot.

I'd compare the available backs across the league rather than assume one teammate will replace all his production. Start with who can actually fill the opening, then check the current role and projection in your scoring format.

Tony Pollard: More Reason to Keep Him in the Conversation ​

Pollard's official Titans game log now gives us three games to compare:

WeekCarriesCatchesTotal yardsTouchdownsFull-PPR points
1713404.4
21416507.5
317496013.6

I'm counting one point per catch and one point per 10 rushing or receiving yards, with no bonuses.

The 21 touches and four catches in Week 3 make me less eager to bench him. His improvement didn't depend on a touchdown, either. I'd keep him rostered and compare him with my actual RB or flex alternative before making a swap.

That still doesn't make him an automatic start. I'd check the upcoming injury reports and whether the receiving work continues. If another player has a clearer role and stronger projection, I'd consider that option. But I'd give the latest workload more weight than my frustration with Week 1.

Colston Loveland: Improvement, but I'd Still Compare Alternatives ​

The Bears' official player page lists five catches for 34 yards and no touchdowns through Week 3. That's an improvement from the one catch for three yards cited in NFL.com's September 23 analysis, but still modest production across three games.

I'd compare him with the tight ends I can actually start in Week 4. If there's an available option with steadier involvement and a stronger projection, I'd consider the change. If the alternatives are just as uncertain, benching Loveland for the sake of doing something doesn't help.

I'd keep him on the bench if I have room and use the next few games to check whether the catches keep coming. One improved week makes me more willing to wait, but it doesn't settle the starting decision.

Who Would You Start Instead? ​

This is where I'd slow down before changing anything. It's easy to decide you're tired of a player. You still have to put someone else in his spot.

I'd compare the two players in my scoring format, check their availability, and make sure both can fill the opening. A receiver might replace Pollard in a flex spot, but he can't solve an RB-only problem.

You can compare two players free in ffwrapped, with no account or league import. Choose your scoring format and check the week. The recommendation uses Sleeper's weekly projections, with recent stats alongside them for context. The opinions above are my reading of the linked reports, not recommendations produced by the tool.

If the projections are almost even, I'd spend more time on the news before making the call. A fraction of a point wouldn't settle it for me. I go through that in more detail in the start/sit walkthrough.

What About Trading Them? ​

For Pollard or Loveland, I'd listen to offers. Achane is a separate keeper or dynasty decision now. Before accepting a deal, I'd set my lineup with the new players and see whether I actually like it better. Getting a disappointing player off the roster can feel good right up until you see who has to replace him.

The early-season trade guide has a worked example of checking both lineups after a deal. If you're worried about the whole team, the team-diagnosis checklist is a better place to start.

For Week 4, I'd fill Achane's lineup spot first, check whether Pollard's receiving work holds up, and compare Loveland with the available tight ends. If the whole roster is struggling, I'd also check my playoff outlook before deciding how much risk to take on a trade.

Last updated: